BSJ suggests that you consult your legal advisor before filing a notice or counter-notice
This kicker might be more appropriate to EDH/Commander games where mana is more plentiful, likewise Master of the Hunt is expensive but if mana is plentiful, it might be an option
This CGC 5.5 has an crease on the back which netted the 5.5 - The grader probably looked at this card and seen this tiny crease and notch on the front corner and was debating between a 5 and 6
The main problem we have here is that this creature just doesnt really do it in modern Magic (I could see this being an uncommon these days!), and the rate wasnt even really good enough when it was first printed, either
Sorry, kiddo, instead of happily ever after, you got diarrhea, fever, and stomach cramps